Why Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson could be playing for his starting job on Sunday vs. Texans — Jimmy Watkins

Deshaun Watson is set to return to his starting role as Cleveland Browns quarterback for Sunday’s game against the Houston Texans, despite a recent concussion and speculation that he might lose his position to Shedeur Sanders. The decision, announced Wednesday by first-year Browns coach Todd Monken, ended a period of uncertainty that fueled rumors of a potential quarterback change.

Monken’s initial silence on the matter sparked considerable speculation. He wouldn’t address the quarterback situation during a Zoom call with reporters on Monday, insisting he wanted to speak with his staff first. He waited until Wednesday to formally announce that he’s sticking with Watson over Sanders, who had some impressive moments in Sunday’s 23-22 overtime loss to the Saints.

The Concussion and the Uncertainty

Watson sustained a concussion during a game against the Pittsburgh Steelers on November 1, where he took a helmet-on-helmet hit from Steelers safety Jaquan Brisker. He missed only one play, finished the game and didn’t show any symptoms until the next day. He was cleared from concussion protocol on Saturday, but the Browns decided to play Sanders, who had taken all the snaps in practice.

Monken explained his rationale for sticking with Watson, emphasizing the quarterback’s overall performance. “I had no intention of Deshaun not being our starter,” he said. “Ultimately the full body of work – the previous eight games that we had played, Deshaun played pretty well. And that was my intention.” He added, “I don’t even know why I have to say it publicly because it’s really only our business in terms of who’s going to play and who’s not going to play.”

Watson's Perspective and Contract

Despite the uncertainty, Watson never doubted he would return to the lineup this week. The 31-year-old also acknowledged the larger context of his situation, noting, “That’s up to Monk and the front office.” Watson is in the final year of the historic $240 million guaranteed contract he signed with the Browns after being acquired from the Texans in a 2022 trade that reshaped both franchises.

The Financial Implications

The weight of Watson’s contract looms large over the Browns' future. The guaranteed money represents a significant financial commitment, and his performance directly impacts the team’s salary cap flexibility. Beyond this season, the Browns have to consider whether to extend his contract or let him test free agency, a decision that will heavily influence their ability to build a competitive roster around him. The pressure is on for Watson to justify this investment and demonstrate sustained success.

The 2022 Trade

The trade that brought Watson to Cleveland was a significant moment for both franchises. The Browns gave up three first-round picks and two third-round picks to acquire him from the Texans, a testament to the team’s belief in his potential. However, Watson's subsequent legal issues and limited performance have put pressure on both him and the Browns organization.

A Gamble That Didn't Pay Off (Yet)?

The trade was seen as a bold move by then-Browns general manager Andrew Berry, signaling the team’s intention to compete for a Super Bowl. The cost, however, was substantial, depleting the Browns' draft capital for years to come. The initial excitement surrounding Watson’s arrival was tempered by his absence during the 2022 season due to legal proceedings and subsequent suspension. Now, with the team facing playoff contention, the pressure is on to see if the gamble will ultimately pay off.

Monken's Reasoning and Sanders' Potential

Monken addressed the possibility of starting Sanders again, stating, “Everything you’re considering, but ultimately Deshaun’s done a really good job for us.” He acknowledged Sanders’ performance in the Saints game, where he passed for 297 yards. “There’s a lot of room for improvement with both of them,” Monken added.

While Sanders showed promise, Monken emphasized Watson's experience and leadership. “Five and three as a starter,” he said, referencing Watson’s record with the Browns. “He’s worked awfully hard to get back. There’s a high belief in that.”

Shedeur Sanders: The Future in Cleveland?

The emergence of Shedeur Sanders has added an intriguing layer to the Browns' quarterback situation. While still a young player, Sanders possesses undeniable talent and a calm demeanor under pressure. His performance against the Saints, despite the loss, demonstrated his potential to lead the offense. The Browns' coaching staff will undoubtedly continue to evaluate Sanders' progress, and he could play a significant role in the team’s future, whether as a starter or a valuable backup.

The Browns' Offensive Struggles

Cleveland's offense has been a source of frustration for fans and analysts alike. Ranked 29th in scoring, the unit has struggled to consistently move the ball and put points on the board. This isn’t solely on Watson; the offensive line has faced challenges, and the receiving corps hasn't always been reliable. The Browns' ability to improve their offensive performance will be crucial for their playoff aspirations.

The Texans Connection

Watson’s return to Houston adds a significant emotional element to the game. The trade that sent him to Cleveland was acrimonious, and the Texans have been rebuilding their franchise since his departure. The game is expected to be highly charged, with both teams eager to prove themselves.

A Rebuilding Texans Franchise

The Houston Texans, after trading Watson, embarked on a significant rebuilding process. They’ve focused on drafting young talent and developing a new team identity. Their progress has been steady, and they present a legitimate challenge to the Browns this season. The game will be a test of how far both franchises have come since the trade that reshaped their trajectories.

Monken's Ambiguity and Future Plans

Monken’s comments regarding Watson’s long-term future were deliberately ambiguous. “I don’t look at it week to week and I don’t look at his long term,” he said. “We’re judged each week. I am. He is. Our team is. I anticipate him being our starter. It’s what he’s been. He’s been our starter. But we all control that.”

The Browns have a bye next week before playing three straight home games against the Denver Broncos, the Baltimore Ravens, and the Pittsburgh Steelers. These games will be crucial in determining the Browns’ playoff prospects and will provide a significant opportunity for Watson to regain his form and solidify his position as the team’s starting quarterback.

Community Reaction and Expectations

The Browns’ muddled quarterbacking history, combined with Monken’s initial silence, fueled speculation about a potential change. However, the decision to stick with Watson has been met with a mix of reactions from fans and analysts. Some express confidence in Watson’s ability to lead the team, while others voice concerns about his recent injury and inconsistent performance. The community will be watching closely to see how the season unfolds and whether Watson can lead the team to a successful finish.